Handcrafted Goodness

Serving Miller Place for Over 15 Years

Order Now

Everyone agrees, It's Better on a Bagel!

Welcome to Better on a Bagel, where every bite brings satisfaction. For over 15 years, we've been a beloved part of Miller Place, crafting handcrafted bagels and offering a full-service deli with Boar's Head products, homemade salads, and sandwiches. Treat yourself to our bakery goods or enjoy specialty coffees and teas. Whether you're dining in our cozy café or grabbing a quick meal, our friendly staff ensures an exceptional experience. Plus, our catering services bring tradition to your doorstep. Discover why it's always better on a bagel with us!

Order Now

highest quality ingredients served fresh every morning

At Better on a Bagel, quality is paramount. Every morning, we begin by selecting the freshest, highest quality ingredients for our handcrafted bagels. From locally sourced produce to premium Boar's Head deli meats and cheeses, we spare no expense to ensure each bite is a taste sensation. Our dedication to freshness and excellence shines through in every aspect of our menu. Whether you're enjoying a classic bagel with cream cheese or one of our specialty sandwiches, you can trust that every ingredient is chosen with care. Come experience the difference at Better on a Bagel, where freshness and flavor meet in perfect harmony.

Browse Menu

THE BEST CATERING SERVICES FOR EVERY OCCASION

Better on a Bagel's catering services are the perfect choice for any event. With a diverse menu featuring handcrafted bagels, gourmet sandwiches, and fresh salads, we cater to all tastes and preferences. Our commitment to quality ensures that every dish is prepared with the finest ingredients, guaranteeing a memorable culinary experience. From corporate meetings to family gatherings, our experienced team will handle every detail with professionalism and care, making your event truly special.

Book Services

where Great Taste Meets Unparalleled Service

At Better on a Bagel, we take pride in serving great-tasting food paired with unparalleled service. From our handcrafted bagels to our gourmet sandwiches and fresh salads, every dish is prepared with care and attention to detail. Our friendly and knowledgeable staff is dedicated to providing exceptional service, ensuring that every customer leaves satisfied. Whether you're dining in our cozy café or enjoying our catering services, you can expect a memorable experience from start to finish. Discover the perfect blend of delicious food and exceptional service at Better on a Bagel.

Learn More

READ REVIEWS FROM OUR SATISFIED CUSTOMERS

Review Us

Miller Place's Favorite Bagel Shop

Better on a Bagel stands out as the premier bagel shop in Miller Place. For over 15 years, we have been a beloved staple in the community, offering handcrafted bagels made from scratch using the finest ingredients. Our dedication to quality and freshness sets us apart, ensuring that every bite is a taste sensation. With a wide variety of flavors and options, there's something for everyone at our shop. Come experience the difference at Better on a Bagel and taste why we're the best in Miller Place.

Get in Touch

Deli Deliciousness and Bakery Bliss

At Better on a Bagel, our deli and baked goods are the epitome of culinary excellence. Step into our shop and experience a tantalizing selection of premium Boar's Head deli meats, cheeses, and homemade salads. From hearty sandwiches to artisanal wraps, each offering is crafted with care and precision to satisfy every palate. Pair your meal with our freshly baked goods, including delectable muffins, pastries, and donuts, for a delightful culinary experience that keeps customers coming back for more.

Call Us

Grab, Go, and Savor

Better on a Bagel's Grab & Go case service offers convenience without compromising on quality. Stocked with a variety of pre-made items and small grocery goods, it's the perfect solution for busy customers on the move. Whether you need a quick breakfast, lunch, or snack, our Grab & Go case has you covered with freshly prepared options. With a focus on freshness and flavor, each item is carefully curated to meet our high standards. Experience the ease and satisfaction of Grab & Go at Better on a Bagel today.

Contact Us

Community First, Bagels Always

Better on a Bagel is an integral part of the Miller Place community, cherished for over 15 years for our dedication to quality and service. We prioritize local sourcing, supporting neighboring businesses, and fostering connections with our customers. Our cozy café serves as a gathering spot where friends and neighbors come together to enjoy delicious food and warm hospitality. From friendly conversations to personalized service, we strive to create a welcoming atmosphere that reflects the spirit of our community.

Get in Touch

Brewed to Perfection

Indulge in a rich and aromatic experience with Better on a Bagel's specialty coffees and teas. Our carefully curated selection includes a variety of blends and flavors to suit every taste preference. From bold espressos to soothing herbal teas, each beverage is expertly brewed to perfection. Whether you're starting your day with a robust cup of coffee or winding down with a calming tea, our specialty drinks are sure to awaken your senses and elevate your mood. Join us and discover the delightful world of Better on a Bagel's specialty coffees and teas.

Contact Us

EVERY BITE IS SERVED WITH A SMILE

At Better on a Bagel, our friendly service is at the heart of everything we do. From the moment you walk through our doors, you'll be greeted with a warm smile and genuine hospitality. Our dedicated staff takes pride in providing personalized attention to every customer, ensuring a positive and memorable experience. Whether you're a regular or a first-time visitor, you'll always feel welcomed and valued at Better on a Bagel. We believe that friendly service is the key to building lasting relationships with our customers, and we're committed to making your visit a delightful one.

Browse Menu

CONTACT Better on a Bagel

Contact Us

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What makes Better On A Bagel so popular?

    At Better On A Bagel, our popularity as a bagel shop is rooted in our dedication to crafting the best bagels in town. We pride ourselves on being a premier bagel shop in the community, offering handcrafted bagels made fresh every morning. Customers love our bagel shop for our wide variety of bagel flavors, ranging from classic favorites to unique specialties. As a bagel shop, we prioritize quality, using only the finest ingredients to ensure that every bite is a delicious experience. Our friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere set us apart as the go-to bagel shop for locals and visitors alike.

  • Does Better On A Bagel deliver?

    Yes, Better on a Bagel offers delivery services through Grubhub. With contact-free delivery, we prioritize the safety and satisfaction of our customers. Additionally, Grubhub+ members enjoy free delivery. Enjoy the convenience of having our delicious bagels and more delivered straight to your doorstep with Better on a Bagel and Grubhub.

  • Can I place a catering order for a specific dietary restriction or allergy?

    Yes, at Better on a Bagel, we cater to specific dietary restrictions and allergies. Our customizable options ensure your catering order meets your needs without sacrificing taste or quality. Simply inform us of any dietary requirements when placing your order, and we'll create a delicious menu tailored to you.

  • Does Better On A Bagel offer custom breakfast/deli party platters?

    Yes, Better On A Bagel offers custom breakfast and deli party platters. Choose from a variety of freshly prepared bagels, cream cheeses, deli meats, and cheeses to create the perfect spread for your event. Contact us to discuss your requirements, and let us make your event unforgettable with our delicious offerings.

bagel shop

Share by: